Ƶ

Will Prosecuting Medical Errors Lead to a Culture of Silence?

— Healthcare workers fearful of repercussions from former nurse RaDonda Vaught's conviction

Ƶ MedicalToday
A photo composite of a photo of Radonda Vaught and a razor wire fence surrounding a penitentiary.

Healthcare workers are alarmed by the , who now faces prison time over a medical error.

"We could all and probably have been close to this situation because we're continuously stretched too thin," Kelsey Fassold, RN, an ICU nurse, . "We try so hard to do the best by our patients while the odds are stacked against us."

Jeremy Faust, MD, Ƶ's editor-in-chief, that the verdict "may contribute to a culture of silence around medical errors."

"Such silence may make systemic problems less readily identified and rectified. This is the opposite of what we need," Faust wrote. "We need to destigmatize human errors, acknowledge them, and learn from them."

On Friday, Vaught was convicted of negligent homicide and gross neglect of an impaired adult, after she allegedly gave 75-year-old Charlene Murphey the paralytic vecuronium when she was meant to give her the anti-anxiety drug Versed. Vaught had been acquitted of a reckless homicide charge.

Vaught faces 1 to 2 years in prison for the negligent homicide charge, and 3 to 6 years on the gross neglect charge, . Her sentencing is scheduled for May 13.

Typically, serious medical errors are handled by licensing boards or civil courts -- not prosecutors.

The American Nurses Association that the "criminalization of medical errors could have a chilling effect on reporting and process improvement."

"ANA supports a full and confidential peer review process in which errors can be examined and system improvements and corrective action plans can be established," the statement said. "Transparent, just, and timely reporting mechanisms of medical errors without the fear of criminalization preserve safe patient care environments."

Faust said that during his career, he witnessed a very similar error. Instead of confusing vecuronium with Versed, Faust said a nurse gave the paralytic rocuronium when she was meant to give the antibiotic Rocephin.

"Fortunately, the mistake was immediately recognized, and the patient suffered no immediate or long-term consequences," Faust wrote. "In fact, the patient was informed as to what was happening in real time, given a play-by-play narration of what had just happened and what would happen next," which included giving Sugammadex to reverse the effects of rocuronium.

"The nurse who made the mistake was experienced, respected, and every bit as caring as the very best healthcare colleagues I have worked with over the years," Faust wrote. "In other words, this was not some green, distracted, or emotionally detached bad apple. In my mind, all of that added up to one thing: this could have happened to anyone."

"If honest errors lead to criminal convictions, every incentive will be to sweep things under the rug," Faust added. "If we don't learn from both our successes and our failures, things will get worse, not better."

Fassold noted in her LinkedIn post that she considered Vaught's mistake a "systemic error" and that "when something bad happened, the nurse took the heat."

"Nurses are constantly put in unsafe and harmful conditions that can and will hurt patients. Not because they're not trying, but because they're working themselves to death trying to keep up with what the system demands from them," she wrote -- a sentiment that has echoed throughout the nursing world as it struggled to provide care through the COVID-19 pandemic.

"Nursing ratios are far worse now than they ever have been," she continued. "How many more situations will occur just like this? It's time nurses stand up for themselves, their license, and their life. It's time nurses say no to unsafe assignments. It's time nurses tell administration that what [they're] demanding is unsafe and harmful. It's time we all stand together and demand change."

Vanderbilt University Medical Center, Vaught's former employer when the error occurred, said via an email from a spokesperson that it did not have a comment on the verdict.

  • author['full_name']

    Kristina Fiore leads MedPage’s enterprise & investigative reporting team. She’s been a medical journalist for more than a decade and her work has been recognized by Barlett & Steele, AHCJ, SABEW, and others. Send story tips to k.fiore@medpagetoday.com.